(title hidden — not yet read)

(summary hidden — not yet read)

On the dusty road north into the heart of Shinovar, Kaladin trudges behind a Szeth who has folded back into himself the moment Nale appeared. Every attempt at conversation gets a monotone two-word answer. Even the texture of the land is wearier here: drier earth, weedier plants, a road wide enough to argue for crowds that never came. Nale strides at the head of the column, somehow staying clean while the other two grow filthy, calling no breaks, expecting them to drink from canteens on the move. He looks, Kaladin notes, exactly like a lighteyes with two sorry soldiers in tow.

Kaladin tries to get Szeth to talk. The little he gets in return — *I have been a handful of times; Lightweaver was not my preferred pair of abilities* — only sharpens his sense that the work he had done with Szeth in the rain has been washed clean off. He sees Tien in the other man and aches to help, and the inability to do anything for him is becoming a physical pain.

Nale invites him in instead. *I hear you've been offering my disciple radical philosophy, Windrunner. Speak.* Without Syl back from scouting, Kaladin gathers what he has and says it plainly: this *follow the law as worship* thing is ridiculous; every rule needs to be broken sometimes. Nale receives the answer with a calm anatomist's interest and starts cutting. Is Kaladin an anarchist? On what authority does he decide which laws to break? Could not every murderer say his case was special? Did not Nohadon himself argue that society requires such rules? *I don't even want to argue with you,* Kaladin says; *I think Szeth should think for himself a little more.* Nale answers that Szeth *is* thinking for himself — that those who advocate free thought tend to recognise free thinking only in people who agree with them.

Kaladin presses on, knowing he is losing on points but right on the merits. He tells Nale what law actually did to him: it let Amaram take his brother to war, and what Sadeas did to bridge crews was perfectly legal. The law can be cruel. *And what replaces it?* Nale asks. *Human decency, maybe?* The law, Nale says, is at least applied; humans cannot be trusted to be decent — Kaladin himself should know this best of all. He concedes, almost in passing, that his own viewpoint can be flawed. But laws have been refined over eons. They have weight. They are not, he insists, merely the ideas of men.

Then he tells Kaladin why. With a gesture at the long brown-green grass and the man-tall yellow flowers, Nale declares that this land was humanity's first home on Roshar and that its laws were laid down by God and by the monarch chosen for that task — Jezrien himself, King of Heralds and Herald of Kings. The Heralds, he adds, came here long ago by reaching out via Elsecalling — Ishar's mastery; Nale's own modest gift — drawn by *the sacred tones of Roshar* like a song calling them home. When Kaladin objects that the Wind itself speaks to him, Nale dismisses it as the dying echo of a god long gone.

The exchange ends where the road does. Szeth has been listening to all of it. Kaladin tries once more — *what you're doing is hurting him; he needs compassion, not a courtroom* — and Nale rounds on him at last with the only attack he has been waiting to land: *Where was your compassion the day you left him to die in the storm?* Szeth, asked if he is ready, says he is. Ready for what, Kaladin asks. Ready, Nale says, *for the Lightweaver monastery, where he will take the Blade from the Honorbearer.* They turn off the main road onto a hidden footpath toward mesas in the lower western mountains, and Kaladin watches Szeth take up his weapons again to resume a mission he has already said he wishes were over.

Far away, Jasnah leaves a long strategy session at Thaylen City with the same nagging sense that something is wrong. Her uniform — fitted bodice, long coat flowing like skirts over trousers, gloves she can fight in — is doing its work; she has become a model for women Radiants whether she wants to be or not, and is always being watched. The session itself went well. The Stonewards are seeding the bay with hidden spikes; the artifabrians have built fabrials that will pick up Deepest Ones coming through stone; the Oathgate is locked and watched in Shadesmar; the sky-arbalests are sighted in; and that very morning a fresh shipment of anti-Voidlight gemstones has arrived to put Fused down for good. Thaylenah has become, as the enemy must know, a single giant fortress with no easy beachhead.

And the enemy is coming anyway.

Jasnah reaches a high window over the blue harbour and admits to Ivory, on her seashell earring, that she does not know what they are missing — only that, deep down, she is sure they are missing something. Ivory considers in his careful inkspren way and tells her that perhaps the council does not need another general here. Perhaps it needs a scholar. She immediately sees that he is right. She is not going to outshoot admirals at tactics; she could spend years and still be their student. But if the impossible question is *how does Odium take an unbreakable city?*, that is a logic problem, not a battle one. She needs paper and silence, and she needs them now.